Have you ever seen a brake like this?

BLACKVIPER

War schon mal da
I drive 30,000 km per year with my Leon St VZ 2.0 and had my first inspection at 30,000 km. About 2-3 weeks prior, the car started making noises inside when I lightly braked at low speeds under 30 km/h. The lighter and slower I braked, the more audible it became. At speeds over 30 km/h or with stronger braking, nothing could be heard. From the outside, absolutely nothing was heard. Sometimes the noise was there, sometimes I didn't hear it for several days. The noise obviously came from one side in the front. It seemed to me that there was a stone in the brake. During the inspection, I mentioned all of this and tried to get them to install new pads and discs – with a warranty and maintenance contract, I wasn't too worried. The result: "Yes, there was dirt in there, we removed it." I couldn't achieve more than that. Therefore, I was skeptical and suspected: that's not enough – but what can you do? So it didn't surprise me that just a few days later, the noises returned. I also brought it up again; they still had to replace the water pump anyway, but I received no further feedback. So I continued driving. Easily 7,000 km. For the most part, it was no longer audible, but it was clear that something was still not right. Recently, I drove about 300 km there and back. On the way back, I had the speedometer at 240 km/h at times and had to brake hard several times. There was nothing to notice. Just as I wanted to park, I drove slowly and braked lightly, thinking I was driving on the rim. The noise was incredibly loud, much louder than ever before. From the outside, you could still hardly hear anything. I measured the brake discs quite cheaply with my Google Pixel; both sides were equally warm. My hand also noticed no difference. The next morning, I called the dealership directly, but the earliest appointment was at the end of the week. Therefore, I tried a different approach, drove to the dealer, and grabbed a helpful employee. A short drive, the noise was quieter due to the cold brakes, but not even a kilometer later, it got louder again. Up on the lift, and then they showed me this:

PXL_20251020_135929530.jpg
PXL_20251020_135930828.jpg
PXL_20251020_140012803.jpg

The friendly dealer said he had never seen anything like it. Yeah, me neither. Have you ever seen something like this, and is my suspicion correct that a stone got lost and then got stuck/burned in?

And to complete the story: After a brief consultation and clarification, the brakes were replaced immediately, so pads + discs in the front. Costs are covered by the maintenance contract
 
To be honest, I've never had such terrible brakes. It's only the 2-liter diesel, but after 22k km: imbalance, squeaking, grinding noises. My 7 GTD didn't have that after over 70k km... but this seems to be a common issue throughout the VAG group.
 
Last edited:
@BLACKVIPER That looks like a material defect in the brake pad to me...

Take a look at the attached photo, it looks quite similar there.
For you, it was almost at the beginning, and I personally find it rather shocking that they let you drive like that - I would look for another workshop.

A stone would have a hard time getting there - due to the small gap between the pads and the disc.
And then there would also be noticeable grooves in the brake disc - with you, it has only been worn down uniformly in the outer area.

You can see nicely above the thumb in your picture how the material of the brake pad is coming apart.

It could also be a misalignment of the brake pad due to incorrect installation - that would explain why the brake pad hasn't worn down evenly.
But it's hard to determine that through such a remote diagnosis...
 

Attachments

  • post-7158-0-42709800-1467711701_thumb.jpg
    post-7158-0-42709800-1467711701_thumb.jpg
    24.7 KB · Views: 31
Last edited:
Ich würde von einem Materialfehler des Bremsbelags ausgehen. Ein Fremdkörper (Stein o.ä.) kommt meiner Meinung nach nicht in Frage.
 

* = Advertisement
Links marked with an asterisk (*) are affiliate links. If you click on one of these links and make a purchase, we receive a commission from the respective online shop or provider. This does not affect the price you pay.

Back
Top