Regenerative braking in hybrids

Das hängt ziemlich sicher mit der Huldigung des CO2-Gottes zusammen, bzw. um den theoretischen Verbrauch zu drücken, wenn kein Sprit fürs Laden draufgehen kann, nach WLTP. Realität interessiert ja niemanden 🫠
 
Ich denke auch, dass die EU Reglementierung dahinter steckt.
Den VFL kann man von 0-96% laden. So habe ich die VFL über den Winter bringen lassen, weil die Ladeinfrastruktur Monate zu spät kam.
Aber auch eine Möglichkeit für die Variante bergab laden, bergauf elektrisch.

Grundsätzlich müsste das Szenario mit dem FL aber geringfügig auch klappen. Wenn es steil genug ist Rekuperation auf STARK, dann solle er selbst ohne Ladestand halten laden. Wenn es nicht ganz so steil ist, auf Automatisch. Dann hält er die Geschwindigkeit und nimmt die Motorbremse nur wenn es schneller wird. Bei letzterem kommt natürlich nicht ganz so viel Ladung dazu.
 
Basically, the scenario with the FL should work slightly as well. If it's steep enough for recuperation to be on STRONG, then it should hold charge even without the battery level.

Um, that's the point of recuperation ;) But I can say (without doing a scientific evaluation of efficiencies, friction, etc.) that recuperating (even on strong) is in no comparison to consumption. Also, the brake energy recovery usually dissipates completely, as the maximum charging power is already "used up" by recuperation.

Here's a simple example (the numbers are arbitrary). I drive up any mountain. In doing so, I consume, for example, 2.5 kWh. If I roll down the same mountain and recuperate the maximum, I only gain 0.3 kWh. Pure recuperation (deceleration) will therefore never make any real sense in relation to the energy needed for propulsion. The imbalance is far too great. It would only seem to make sense if one outsourced the consumption side and then removed it from the calculation (as is often done with wind power and other great achievements). So I passively get the car onto a transporter up the mountain and then let it roll down while recuperating. In the car, I have then achieved an effective energy gain. In the overall view, however, this is of course huge nonsense.

Recuperation is therefore a nice gimmick, which makes sense in that it is there, and then you can take the drop. But to plan it out properly, I find extremely quirky :sneaky:

I would consider targeted charging, like in the 1st generation hybrids, to be much more sensible. Especially due to the (due to WLTP) tiny fuel tanks. Theoretically, one could even optimize this with AI by now and achieve a significant improvement in efficiency. But by the time VAG could technically get this right, all of humanity would have long since relocated to another galaxy :ROFLMAO:
 
@nersd
Very well written.(y) The whole thing is also easily transferable: My two eBikes with Alber Neodrives rear motors can also recuperate when braking downhill, but this is equally disproportionate to the energy required to climb the same hill. You need 8% battery power uphill, but downhill you recover—if at all—just about 1%. Many people consider the advertising for this to be nothing but a con.
 
I admit, originally I had expected much (much much) more from the energy recuperation. In theory, it sounds great. The reality was very sobering for me. In practice, it doesn’t even compensate for the general charging losses.
 
Somewhere in Austria (I think) there is a quarry open-pit mine on top of a mountain where the spoil is transported down into the valley by a purely electric dump truck.

Because of the enormously high weight going downhill, the dumper is charged strongly enough (by recuperation) that it actually manages to get back up the mountain empty.
And then it starts all over again 🙃
 
@nersd That’s not what I meant; I was referring to the topic of charging while driving. With the pre-facelift (VFL), you can’t drive purely electrically during the charging phase either (although energy is used for “boost” during acceleration).
So if I maintain the charge level on a route with a facelift (FL) model, and then additionally recuperate downhill, it should increase the charge level, then update to maintain that charge level at the bottom, and it would hold the increased level. It’s only marginal, but it would be an option (whether it’s useful or not is another question).

In the end, you don’t really need that. If you maintain the battery level from the start and switch deliberately where it’s better to use electric power, that’s better in my opinion.
I generally keep at least 50% charge for traffic jams on the motorway, and if it’s not needed, I use it at the end. City traffic or going uphill always comes last.

It’s perfectly clear to me that energy consumption is fundamentally greater than energy recovery 😉
 
@nersd That’s not what I meant; I was referring to the topic of charging while driving. With the pre-facelift (VFL), you can’t drive purely electrically during the charging phase either (but energy is used for “boost” during acceleration).
So if I maintain the charge level on a route with a facelift (FL) model, and then additionally recuperate downhill, it should increase the charge level, then update to maintain the charge level at the bottom, and then it holds the increased level. It’s only marginal, but it would be a possibility (whether it’s sensible or not is another matter).

In the end, you don’t really need that; if you maintain the battery level from the start and switch deliberately where you drive better electrically, that’s better in my opinion.
I generally keep at least 50% charge for traffic jams on the motorway, and if it’s not needed, I use it at the end. City traffic or uphill always comes at the end.

It’s clear to me that energy consumption > energy recovery in principle 😉

Yes, even during charging there are sections driven purely electrically. Especially when starting off or at very low speeds. At least that was the case with the mechanically identical Octavia. So charging wasn’t a dogma, but the rough goal of the car.

I know what you mean; I was the first to criticise the lack of charging here in the Forum. I simply see it as a deficiency and a self-limitation of the technology.

But I have no desire to constantly juggle with charging behaviour, holding, not holding, etc. The operation is already way too stupid and operation-heavy for me. I want to drive the car, not constantly fiddle around and have my eyes more on the display than on the road. That’s why a simple charging function would be so important. For me, especially with regard to optimising range (the Octavia had a 35L tank! and the 40L in the Cupra is just as much a joke, especially since it consumes more and in the end has the same range with 5L more fuel tank and 10 kWh more battery as the Octavia).
 
For me, especially regarding range optimization (the Octavia had a 35L tank! and the 40 in the Cupra is just as much of a joke, especially since it consumes more and in the end has the same range as the Octavia with 5L more tank and 10 kWh more battery).

I find the 40 liters more than sufficient. I can get over 1,000 km on a full tank in hybrid mode, which I actually use all the time. My long-term consumption over 19,000 km is 3.4l/100km and 12.6kWh/100km, and for me, it's quite "hilly."
 
Last edited:
I just want to quickly add my "two cents" here, but without criticising anyone or anything...

For my part, I am absolutely satisfied with the hybrid as it is; I also gathered a lot of information beforehand about what works and what doesn’t. The idea, as I see it, behind the hybrid is simply that your daily trips of less than about 80 km can be driven purely electrically. That means commuting to work, shopping, etc., and there’s no need to switch the combustion engine back on to generate electricity (which probably isn’t the point of driving a hybrid under EU regulations if it ends up burning more fuel again). For longer range, there is the hybrid and the combination of both. For most average consumers, this scenario will apply and be completely sufficient. How @Tygulav wrote, I can also manage over 1000km with mine, so the tank is more than sufficient in size.

But I can also understand your points @nersdI think nowadays there really shouldn’t be any hybrids anymore; if you give people too many options, it can only lead to confusion or something like that. Either purely combustion engine or purely electric, and that’s it. But that’s just my opinion!

I believe that if I had to get a car today, I would probably switch to fully electric already, but I was still a bit sceptical about the whole thing and wanted to test the waters with a hybrid first.

I just wanted to share my own thoughts and am not trying to attack anyone!! 🙈
 
I can cover over 1,000 km on a single tank in hybrid mode, which I actually always use.

No way! With 20 kWh (at best 90 km) plus 40L of petrol (at best 550 km), I consider 1,000 km in real life impossible. Even driving constantly at 30 km/h on a straight road without traffic lights, traffic, or anything else. In hybrid mode with normal use (rarely over 160 km/h), I get around 600 km (+/-). In winter, less, because the electric range drops significantly and fuel consumption with the combustion engine also increases slightly.

And I have been driving a plug-in hybrid for over 5 years now.
 
It naturally depends on the usage. I mostly drive urban (commuting) and maybe once a month about 50km on the motorway. I suspect you drive a lot on the motorway, and personally, I find a PHEV to be the wrong choice for that.

But why should I tell nonsense here? It is MY consumption, linked below from last year

Edit: I refuelled yesterday. Consumption between the refuelling stops: 2.5l/100km and 11.4kwh/100km, 1,428km and average speed 43.7km/h.
In the end, I drove quite a bit in electric mode and cautiously. On country roads, 70-80km/h when there was no one behind me. If there was someone behind me, then also 100 (when allowed) to avoid causing traffic disruption.

https://cupra.forum/threads/reichweite-verbr%C3%A4uche-1-5-ehybrid.201/post-21277?rf=87

But I am there at @Ice-MarkAs of today, I either have a fully electric vehicle or a combustion engine, which is why I'm currently opting for a pure combustion engine again.
 
Last edited:
The data in the app is nonsense. For me, it shows 4.7L per 100 km and 7.9 kWh per 100 km. You can’t calculate the real consumption for a full depletion of both systems with that data at all.

You claim you can go from Flensburg to Freiburg in one go without needing to refuel or recharge. And that is simply not possible (not even at 30 km/h)! No way!
As I said, I’ve been driving a hybrid for over 5 years (about 120,000 km). That thing would then have more range than many diesels. With 40 litres of petrol and just under 20 kWh :ROFLMAO: Pure nonsense!
 
Reading doesn't seem to be your strong suit, does it? Where do I claim that I achieve these values on long distances? I'm talking about MY values! MY driving profile, MY route, which is mostly in an urban environment. I find it quite presumptuous of you to accuse me of "lying" just because it doesn't fit YOUR driving profile! Furthermore, I never wrote that I wouldn't need to charge at 1,000 km! I said with a FULL TANK, and I mostly drive in hybrid mode! Of course, you regularly charge the PHEV at the cable; if you don't do that, you shouldn't buy a PHEV. That's my opinion!

And of course, I don't reach 1,000 km on long distances, more like ~600 km. However, I only drive such a distance twice a year, and it doesn't bother me at all to have to refuel in between. If I had to drive such a distance regularly, I would have bought a diesel!
Sorry to everyone else for the off-topic, I'm out of this conversation now.
 
Last edited:
Then this 1.8-tonne lump would be by far the most efficient and economical vehicle on this planet. And I’m saying, no matter what driving profile. 1000 km in one go without refuelling or charging—never! I won’t be convinced otherwise because it’s nonsense. If that were actually the case, VW would market this thing very differently.

And that you’re constantly charging in between, you haven’t mentioned anywhere so far!!! Such a lie is quickly exposed 🤷‍♂️
Shall I tell you something? I can easily manage 10 or 20,000 km on a single tank. :ROFLMAO:
 
You still haven't understood it, so please refer to post 34 by @Tygulav read it again, the 1,000 km are not in one go, but with one tankful and MULTIPLE charges!
If it wasn’t clear enough in the post you quoted, he clarified it again there. That settles the matter.
 
You still haven't understood it, so please read the posts by @Tygulav read again, the 1,000 km are not in one go, but with one tank of fuel and MULTIPLE charges!

However, he only admitted this in his third post on the matter! Before that, he simply left out the constant "charging". And who gives such fantasy ranges? If someone says they can go 1000 km, then it is absolutely clear what they mean. There is no other way to interpret it. That way, anyone can throw some fantasy number into the room, and it somehow turns out to be correct. Of course, I can also go from Flensburg to Freiburg on one tank. Even constantly at over 200 km/h.

You just have to charge 10-15 times in between.
 
You can also get from the Baltic Sea to Croatia on one tank if you charge several times along the way. Yes, it wasn’t entirely clear at first what he meant, but he clarified that later. He wasn’t trying to pull the wool over our eyes here; the figure (as you noticed) was too unrealistic for just one refuel and charge. What one person means isn’t necessarily what the other understands. Now everyone should have a 🍺 first and then calm down again.

I’m starting to tackle the topic of door insulation, the material has just arrived..✌️
 
But he only admitted that in his third post! Before that, he simply omitted the constant "charging." And who gives such fantastical ranges? When someone says they can go 1000km, it's absolutely clear what they mean. There is no other interpretation possible. Anyone can throw out some fanciful number that somehow seems to fit. Of course, I can also make it from Flensburg to Freiburg on a single tank. Even while constantly going over 200 km/h.

Just have to charge 10-15 times in between.

One last time from me: My "fantasy value" comes from the fact that I actually assumed that pretty much everyone recharges a PHEV when the battery is empty. Isn't that the purpose of the charging port? Sure, if I only recharge and drive exclusively in e-mode, I could also go 20,000km on a single tank, but then I might as well have gotten a pure electric vehicle. But as I've mentioned several times, I spend most of my time in hybrid mode and less in pure e-mode. I won't let that be taken away from me.

Where does it say that you are constantly charging in between?

Sorry that I didn't make that information clear from the start. For me, it was actually obvious that when it says tank filling, it only refers to the tank. I didn't write about a charge and a tank filling. :unsure:

And sorry to @nersd for the first sentence in post #34.
 
Last edited:

* = Advertisement
Links marked with an asterisk (*) are affiliate links. If you click on one of these links and make a purchase, we receive a commission from the respective online shop or provider. This does not affect the price you pay.

cupra.forum · Alle Rechte vorbehalten · Dies ist kein Forum der Seat Cupra S.A.U.
Back
Top